Monday, 23 March 2015

work progress

we have written a story. this will be a story of soil. we still struggle with a choice of the final format - film or photo essay. the choice very much depends on technical support and time constraints. although film seems to me more concise, it is also has a certain problem - it is much more difficult to include various sorts of materials we have collected due both technical, and copyright issues. Film looks to me now as more autonomous project in which the author has to do more and create content. the more usual genre of essay seems to be more hybrid, open to incorporation of various things, including multimedia through references. this is because the reader seems to be a more active and unrestricted actor, in comparison to viewer of the film. the latter, especially if accompanied by other viewers (like during our screenings at class) is disciplined to watch the film from the beginning to end. but the reader can just scan through photos, or read some bits, choose to follow references or not. if i could i would have made this projects in a form of a video game :) so that the viewer would have been obliged to make decisions on what thread of the story she wanted to follow.
maybe we can think about the technical possibilities of this. but I doubt we can do it in such a short time. 

Tuesday, 17 March 2015

some photos from the field

photographer Svetlana Poleschuk









Multiple temporalities of film production

Work in progress
The project will be a result of patchwork. This will be a film, with a soundtrack that hides strong wind blows, with the insertions from an interview that we recorded in English about the history of the place. As simple as possible. And even this now seems to me a complicated task of cutting.
This will also be an attempt to turn my inability to fix the camera to the tripod into an artful gesture J
Now I see that to make a comfortable for the audience shooting and keep it on the level of observational cinema is actually a very difficult technical task for the cameraman.
But at the same time my poor skills help to decide what to include into 6-8 minute film from more than an hour of footage. We have something about 10 minutes altogether of a good material. And there are only 5 and a half minutes of interview.
But after I was comforted with this shortage, a new challenge came.

It turned out that this is actually a lot! It seems to me that at the time of cutting the timeline of the footage is multiplying. It is as if you are finding yourself suddenly in a different time scale. It is certainly a different temporality. On every minute of the final film you spend hours of your time. Finally, 7 minute film will be a condensed version of the time that equates to several days spent on its production. Interesting, that with ethnography it is the same. You spend a year in the field, to remember several hours of really important action, and then you spend years to write about these hours. You jump between these various temporalities.

Monday, 2 March 2015

project:
this weekend I investigated the situation around the golf-club project and found out that although it looks as if it is abandoned, it is not. The owners of the land had to sell it to another firm because of the credit which they could not pay back. But last week there was a meeting of the representatives of the project with the head of local administration. they showed a new version of the project. There are plans that by 2020 there will be a golf resort in the area.
So we witness how neoliberal projects are being frozen, but not abandoned. Dreams stay, and even develop, as the investors provide a new architectural project of the club. And simultaneously, these dreams prevent the re-cultivation of the territory and actually contribute to conservation. The building of the TS (kolkhoz) situated on the lands sold for the golf project stay there with all the furniture and infrastructures untouched. The territory is closed and nobody still anything from the place. it can be seen as a historical artefact of the gone era, and neoliberal dreaming is contributing to this preservation. I plan to study this paradox by contrasting the images from the project portfolio and images of the real state of the lands.
but i do not want to create a binary opposition, instead to see how dreams and material object coevolve with each other. What is in the golf-projects images taken from "reality" and what role does this play there? And how do dreams shape the real things we witness?


Monday, 23 February 2015

The film Forest of Bliss to me looked very professional. I wonder how this effect is created. Is it just a result of a multiplicity of various perspectives, from which we see the scenes, as if there are many cameras working in the field? Or is it because there are no interactions between the cameraman and the subjects? Or is it because aesthetics seem to be more prominent than other topics, such as a narrative about particular event or a ritual?

Does this effect or image of visual professionalism changes in time? For example, various digital special effects are now almost inevitable part of professional films produced by the industry. Does it mean that in some time ethnographic films will need to use same effects or animation to look updated and professional themselves?

Even ethnographers are doing their film for the audience, and this means that if audience is changing, getting accustomed to particular visual standards, than ethnographic films have to absorb these standards. For example, many contemporary ethnographic films use short cuts, with fast changing images, so to look familiar to the audience trained to watch advertising clips and action films.
The debate around the Forest of Bliss seems to be preoccupied with the autonomy of anthropology from the surrounding environments, including film industry. Such autonomy seems to me impossible, and that is why I am not worried about the penetration of new visual technics.  I am worried about the demand for professionalization that such absence of autonomy creates. We cannot pretend that our amateurish film-making is enough for the purposes of the anthropological discipline. We have to develop professionally looking films, otherwise nobody will watch them. Does that mean that we have to work in collaboration with professional film makers? How can we integrate such collaborations with our fieldworks and difficult ethical problems connected with them? 

Monday, 16 February 2015

Thoughts about the possible visual project



I want to do a photographic essay, but the one that would combine visual images produced by people and those taken by my collaborator and me. There is a web that represents the project of a golf-club, intended to be built in the vicinity of one Hungarian village. The project started before the Global Financial crisis in 2008 and after the bankruptcy left the unfinished landscape of the golf club. The territory is fenced and abandoned. The web site shows photos of the construction as evidence of the potential of the project to attract investments and sell apartments that were planned to build nearby. Through reconstructing the photographic process by trying to produce photos that would be a double to the authentic initial ones we do not only create the classical pair of before and after, but also would analyze how project presentation is built up, and what constitutes the world of dreaming about neoliberal projects, such as international golf-clubs in Hungarian countryside. 




Monday, 9 February 2015

Bad Photos, Moments of Resistance






During our fieldwork among Evenki we had an interesting problem. There were moments that we desperately wanted to document and make a photo, because we knew in advance that we will write something about them and it would be nice to have a picture to put into text as illustration. But we constantly failed to make such pictures. For example, every morning in the Evenki camp started with sprinkling fresh tea into the fire. I planned to make a picture of this everyday ceremony for almost a month, and although I got the opportunity to make it every day, I never managed. Somehow, this simple act was to such an extent part of awakening process of the whole family including us that I was never prepared to use a camera. I lived in a same rhythm with other members and never could step outside this flow to document it. I always remembered about the camera, when the ceremony was already in progress. It was systematically unremarkable event, routine and not pompous at all. Finally, once the same ritual was conducted for other purposes and in other time. But now this was not about starting a day, the same sequence of actions was conducted before sending hunters on their trip. So although, actions were the same but surrounding elements differed, the context was different. The light was bright and the contrast of the picture was harsh. No any trait of those mystic twilights in which this was usually done in the morning. There was snow melting on the stove, when usually there is a pot there in the morning. It was already warm, and you cannot see the stiff figure of the praying woman. From this photo you do not have the impression of how cold it is in the morning, how anticipated is this fresh warm tea is. So on a close inspection, although this photo provides all the formal resemblance with what I intended to document, it showed a totally different mood. And was a bad photo, a wrong one. Perhaps, sometimes we need to accept that some moments are impossible to make a photo about. ‘Reality’ shows its resistance.